1. Does BMI measure body fat percentage?
No. BMI only uses height and weight—it doesn't distinguish muscle from fat. A bodybuilder and a sedentary person
could have identical BMIs despite vastly different body compositions. For body fat percentage, you need specialized
testing like DEXA scans, hydrostatic weighing, or bioelectrical impedance analysis (though accuracy varies).
2. Why do some athletes have "overweight" or "obese" BMI?
Muscle is denser than fat. Athletes with significant muscle mass weigh more than their height would "predict"
using BMI standards. For example, many NFL players have BMIs over 30 (classified as obese) despite having low
body fat percentages. This is why BMI should be used alongside other health indicators.
3. Are the calorie estimates exact?
No calculator can provide exact calorie needs. The Mifflin-St Jeor formula has ~10% margin of error, meaning
your actual needs could be 200-300 calories different from the calculation. Individual factors like genetics,
thyroid function, gut microbiome, and metabolic adaptation affect actual calorie burn.
4. Why do different calculators give different calorie recommendations?
Different formulas exist (Mifflin-St Jeor, Harris-Benedict, Katch-McArdle), each with slightly different calculations
and assumptions. Activity multipliers also vary between calculators. This is normal—treat all estimates as starting
points and adjust based on real-world results.
5. Can I use this for weight loss planning?
Yes, as a starting point. Use the calculated calorie targets, track your food intake and weight for 2-3 weeks,
then adjust based on results. Combine with balanced nutrition and regular exercise. For complex health situations
or significant weight loss goals, work with healthcare professionals.
6. What if my BMI is "normal" but I don't look or feel healthy?
BMI doesn't tell the whole story. You could have normal BMI with high body fat percentage, poor muscle mass,
and metabolic issues (sometimes called "skinny fat"). Focus on body composition through strength training, measure
waist circumference, and monitor health markers like blood pressure and cholesterol.
7. How often should I recalculate my calorie needs?
Recalculate after losing or gaining 5-10 lbs (2.5-5 kg), as your calorie needs decrease with weight loss and
increase with weight gain. Also recalculate if your activity level changes significantly (new job, new exercise
routine, injury recovery).
8. Why am I not losing weight at the calculated deficit?
Common reasons: underestimating food intake (portions are larger than you think), overestimating activity/exercise,
water retention (especially for women during hormonal fluctuations), metabolic adaptation, inaccurate food labels,
or not giving enough time (need 2-3 weeks to see trends). Solution: track more carefully, be patient, or slightly
reduce calories.
9. Is it safe to eat below my BMR?
Generally not recommended without medical supervision. Eating well below BMR can trigger metabolic adaptation,
muscle loss, hormonal disruption, and nutrient deficiencies. Women shouldn't go below 1200 cal/day, men not below
1500 cal/day, except under medical guidance.
10. Does this calculator store my health data?
No. All calculations happen locally in your browser. No personal data is collected, stored, or transmitted to any
server. Your privacy is completely protected. If you refresh the page, you'll need to re-enter your information.
11. Can I use this during pregnancy or while breastfeeding?
While you can calculate baseline BMI, pregnant and breastfeeding women have significantly different calorie needs
and appropriate BMI ranges. Pregnancy requires ~300-500 extra calories daily (2nd/3rd trimester), breastfeeding
~450-500 extra. Always consult your OB/GYN or healthcare provider for personalized guidance during these periods.
12. What's the difference between BMR and TDEE?
BMR (Basal Metabolic Rate) is calories burned at complete rest for basic bodily functions. TDEE (Total Daily Energy
Expenditure) is BMR multiplied by activity factor—it includes all calories burned throughout the day from movement,
exercise, digestion, etc. To maintain weight, eat at TDEE. To lose weight, eat below TDEE. To gain, eat above it.
13. Do men and women have different calorie needs at the same size?
Yes. Men typically have higher muscle mass and lower body fat percentage than women at equivalent heights/weights,
so they burn more calories at rest. This is why the formula adds 5 calories for men but subtracts 161 for women.
Additionally, hormonal differences affect metabolism and fat storage patterns.
14. How does age affect calorie needs?
Metabolism naturally slows with age, primarily due to muscle mass loss. The formula subtracts 5 calories per year of age.
This is why maintaining muscle through strength training becomes increasingly important as you age—it helps preserve
metabolic rate and functional independence.
15. Should I eat the same calories every day?
Not necessarily. Some people find success with calorie cycling (higher calories on training days, lower on rest days)
or intermittent fasting approaches. What matters most is your weekly average. Consistency in average intake matters
more than daily perfection. Some flexibility day-to-day can improve adherence.